Featured on the Tales to Terrify Podcast 

Flossie’s primary concern on the day of her coming-out party wasn’t whether her hair would hold its curl or if a suitable boy would ask her to dance, but whether or not Victoria would dare to show her wretched face. 

“This is supposed to be my special day,” she complained to her maid, who was fussing with the feathers in Flossie’s hair. “And I simply cannot stand the thought of her ruining it.”

“Best not to dwell on it, Miss,” murmured her maid around a mouthful of hairpins. “If she does show up, the other guests will ignore her, like they’ve done before.”

“Even so, it’s off-putting,” Flossie said, pouting at herself in the mirror. “She spoils the mood.”

Her maid finished securing the last feather, then knelt and deftly guided Flossie’s feet into a pair of delicate, pointed shoes. 

“Even if she stands there and says nothing,” Flossie continued, “the very sight of her turns my stomach.”

“She can’t help looking the way she does,” chided her maid. “Plus, there’s no use getting worked up over it. You could, but it would be as useless as kicking the wall with your bare foot. Look, you’re getting all flushed just thinking about it.”

Flossie stopped pouting and fanned herself with her hand. As much as she hated to admit it, her maid was right. The very fact that she was spending these final moments before her debut fretting over Victoria was vexing. 

She did her very best to push Victoria from her mind, but she couldn’t quite manage it. Nor could she banish the image of Victoria from two years ago, sprawled in the mud, limbs twisted at terrible angles, at the foot of her overturned carriage.  

#

In the receiving line, Flossie stood next to her mother, as elegant and poised as a statue, eyeing the guests as they paraded through the door. The evening was shaping up to be quite a success. The foyer and ballroom were aglow with soft, flickering candles and spilled over with clusters of pale pink roses. The buffet table proffered tiny crystal glasses of sparkling punch, along with a vast assortment of delicacies, from lobster vol-au-vants to pastel petit fours. The crowning jewel, hovering above their heads in the grand foyer, was the magnificent three-tiered glass chandelier, ordered from Venice and delivered just days ago. It was furnished with electric lighting, a new and thrilling invention that few in town could afford. Flossie was afraid it wouldn’t arrive in time for her party, but her father assured her that it would be installed on schedule and in perfect accordance with her wishes.

Flossie adjusted the pearl and diamond aigrette adorning her head, smoothing the feathers. Her mother pinched her elbow at once. “Stop fidgeting,” she clipped through a clenched smile. 

Flossie obeyed and craned her neck to look at the line stretching through the open doorway. Their town was small, and so it was crucial for all of the invited guests to be present. She had attended coming-out parties where the room had felt positively cavernous, the dance floor noticeably sparse. It was an embarrassment she couldn’t fathom suffering herself.

But there was no danger of that tonight. The room was already flush with ladies and gentlemen wearing their finest. Several promising young men had already requested dances. And best of all, there was no sign of Victoria.

#

“Two seasons now without a marriage proposal,” Flossie’s mother tutted. “That doesn’t bode well for any young lady.”

Flossie turned toward the girl in question, pushing aside a wave of uneasiness. Katrina was a dear friend of hers. It was unfortunate that her own coming-out party had coincided with all that unpleasantness with Victoria. It was as if the carriage accident had left an indelible mark upon Katrina that couldn’t be scrubbed away, no matter how hard her mother tried. Katrina’s family had organized a ball just a few months earlier to try and make up for her disastrous debut. But Victoria simply glided through the doors and ruined that one, too.

“Mark my words,” Flossie’s mother continued. “That poor Katrina has ‘spinster’ written all over her.”

The word sent a shiver rippling over Flossie’s silk-enveloped shoulders. She imagined herself trapped in such a fate. Forced to care for her aging parents. Shunned from every social event. Fading from relevance before she even hit thirty. 

And if she dared to buck societal expectations, refused to play the role of the dutiful old maid—well, that wasn’t any better, was it? She saw what happened to women like old Hallie, women who lived alone on the fringes of town. Whenever they ventured out, people turned their backs or spat on the ground to ward off a curse. Everyone said the fire that took Hallie’s house—and her life—had been an accident, but Flossie had her doubts. ‘Spinster’ was a terrible title to earn, but ‘witch’ was worse, wasn’t it?

She was so lost in her rumination that she failed to catch the hush that had fallen over the room, sudden as a snuffed-out candle. Her mother’s grip tightened painfully on her arm, the nails digging into her flesh, and Flossie finally turned with a gasp.

Victoria stood framed in the open doorway.

#

The musicians froze in the middle of their gavotte, their bows trembling above the strings.

“Keep playing!” Flossie’s father shouted. He snapped his fingers at the conductor, trying to catch his attention. But the dance floor was already clearing, several people crossing themselves as they detached from their partners.

“Don’t react,” hissed Flossie’s mother in her ear. “If you stay calm, others will, too. “Keep your head up. And for goodness sake, keep smiling.” 

Flossie tried to follow her mother’s instructions, but it was impossible to stop the rush of blood to her head. Her pulse fluttered high and frantic in her throat as she stared at the forlorn figure. Victoria stood there in the limp, greying gown she always wore. She hovered on her toes, her head cocked crookedly to the side, looking around the room with those odd pale eyes of hers. Her skin had a grayish cast to it, the gruesome marks of the carriage accident still etched onto her face. A foul stench rose from the folds of her clothing, like something damp had been put away and left to molder. 

The guests were departing in droves. Ladies clutched their escorts as they skirted around Victoria, like mice darting past a sleeping fox. Those who were brave enough to remain huddled close together, their nostrils flaring in barely-concealed disgust. 

Flossie felt a brush of warmth as Katrina and their friend Cecilia flocked to her side. 

“Don’t acknowledge her,” Cecilia said, echoing Flossie’s mother. “Trust me, you’ll only make it worse.”

But Flossie was now trembling with unrestrained rage. How dare she show up here? Victoria had already ruined Katrina’s coming-out party and Cecilia’s birthday party. Was it too much to ask that she leave Flossie in peace? Flossie hadn’t been the one to loosen the carriage linchpins that night. That had been Teddy’s doing. Flossie and her friends had merely given him the idea. 

Flossie’s brother sauntered over, clutching two glasses of punch in his meaty fists. Teddy’s unsteady gate and unfocused gaze indicated that he was already deeply inebriated. 

“Bad luck, Sis,” Teddy said to Flossie, raising one of his punch glasses. He tossed the beverage back and belched loudly. “Though, good luck to me, I suppose. I bet Alfie five dollars that Victoria would make an appearance tonight.”

“No one wants her here,” Flossie said plaintively. “Why does she keep showing up?”

“It’s unconscionable,” Katrina offered, with a scathing glance at the doorway. “Her mother should get better control over her.”

Teddy gave her an amused look over the rim of his empty glass. “And how would she accomplish that, do you suppose?”

Katrina flushed. “I don’t know,” she replied with a scowl. “There must be something she could do to get her to leave us alone. Hasn’t she caused enough damage already?”

“My mother thinks she’s still trying to find a husband,” Cecilia said. “That’s why she keeps coming to all our parties.”

At that, Teddy let out a loud, brutish bark of laughter. “A husband? A bit late for that now. And isn’t that what landed her in this situation in the first place? Throwing herself at your fellow during Katrina’s coming-out?”

“They were only dancing,” Cecilia replied. “That’s hardly a crime.”

“The rumor was that they were doing a good deal more than just dancing,” Katrina spat, with some venom.

“You should know, since you started that rumor,” Cecilia shot back.

Their voices cut like whips through the air, and Flossie began to feel faintly sick. The feathers on her aigrette were starting to chafe something dreadful.

This was what always happened. People started rehashing the scandal, the shock of Cecilia’s broken engagement, and of course, the details of the horrid carriage accident, until all the attention was focused squarely on Victoria. 

“Oh, please,” Katrina said, rolling her eyes to the heavens. “Anyone with half a brain could tell something was going on between them.”

“We don’t know that,” Cecilia replied. “I think he asked her to dance because he felt sorry for her. She never had any partners.”

“Oh, now you’re defending her?” Katrina said with a bitter cackle. “You were the one who came crying to us when you saw them dancing together.”

“That’s right,” Flossie chimed in. “If you had just ignored them, you’d be married now and none of this would have happened.” She flung her hand towards Victoria, who was still standing in the foyer, her head tilted to the side. She was now rocking slightly back and forth on her toes.

“How was I supposed to know it would all end so badly? It was supposed to be a harmless prank.” Cecilia jabbed her finger at Teddy’s chest. “He’s the one who—”

“Keep your voice down,” Teddy hissed, snatching her hand. 

Cecilia let out a soft yelp and several people looked their way. Teddy was breathing hard and beginning to sweat. The collar of his starched shirt was damp, the fabric drooping around his knotted tie.

“What? Afraid someone will find out what you did?” Cecilia said to Teddy, yanking her hand out of his grasp.

“Oh, leave him alone,” Katrina spat. “You’re just upset because you’re afraid you’ll end up ruined—like me.”

Cecilia’s laugh was too loud, bordering on unhinged. “All of us are ruined! Look around,” she howled, waving to the near-empty ballroom. “With that girl following us around like a hound on our heels, who would want us?”

The words fell like blunt sword on Flossie’s neck. Cecilia was right, she could tell by the way people were steadfastly avoiding her gaze. The buffet table was largely untouched, all the delectable food destined to spoil. Every boy who’d written his name on Flossie’s dance card had fled. The doors had swung firmly shut on all her prospects before they had barely opened. And it was all Victoria’s fault. 

 Flossie’s rage collected behind her eyes and focused itself squarely on the lone figure swaying in the doorway. Why was Victoria so intent on punishing her? They hadn’t meant any harm. They had simply intended to teach Victoria a lesson—to shake her up a bit for her slight against Cecilia.

And of course, of course, of course, they hadn’t intended to kill her.

#

“Maybe I should ask her to dance,” Teddy ventured. He tossed back the contents of his recently-refilled punch glass and handed it to Flossie.

“Are you out of your mind?” she replied.

“Oh, come on. Cecilia said she never had any partners. Maybe this is what she’s waiting for.”

“Waiting for?”

“You know,” he said, flapping his hand. “Before she can cross over, or whatnot.”

“Teddy, don’t you dare,” Katrina hissed. “Flossie, stop him!”

But Teddy was already sauntering into the foyer toward the specter, and Flossie’s pointed shoes were firmly fixed to the ground in fear. She could only watch helplessly as her brother held out his hand to Victoria with a flourish and executed a sloppy bow.

“May I have this dance, m’lady?”

Gasps echoed around the ballroom. Flossie’s heart hammered like a funeral drum in her chest. 

No one ever approached Victoria. The unwritten rule was that if you stayed, you pretended to ignore her. At Cecilia’s eighteenth birthday party, when Victoria appeared for the first time, barely a week after they buried her, Cecilia’s fiancé attempted to toss a tablecloth over Victoria’s head. He’d wanted to spare the ladies the sight of her, but lost his nerve at the last moment. 

He left town soon after.

Flossie held her breath, counting the seconds. Alongside her mounting horror grew a profound curiosity at how Victoria would react. Across the ballroom, the remaining guests were silent, watching with rapt attention.

Victoria’s wide eyes darted over Teddy. Her head tilted further toward her shoulder, the bones of her broken neck jutting out grotesquely.  

“What do you say?” Teddy slurred. “Do you want to take a spin around the ballroom or not?” He leaned closer to Victoria, his mouth inches from her face. “You want to dance, don’t you, you wretched thing? Well, here’s your chance.”

Victoria opened her gash of a mouth, and an odd buzzing sound filled the room. It was distinct and chilling, like a swarm of spiders were crawling up Flossie’s back. She couldn’t fathom where it was coming from until a louder popping sound joined the strange noise. Flossie looked up, and everything clicked into place. 

The electric chandelier was swaying violently.

 Three hundred pounds of Venetian glass chattered overhead as the canopy cracked away from the ceiling. Several wires whipped loose, thrashing around like wild snakes. 

“Look out—” someone shouted, but the voice was drowned out by the eruption of alarmed screams around the room.

Teddy slowly turned his gaze upward, just as the chandelier fell thunderously down.

The crash felt like a thousand shards of glass splintering through Flossie’s core. For a long moment, shock froze her solidly to the floor. She couldn’t move, or breathe, or think of anything beyond the sight of Teddy sprawled under the chandelier, nearly hidden from view under three tiers of shattered glass. 

And then voices began boring into her brain, puncturing through the fog like tiny, incessant needles.

“My god, is he alright?”

“Someone fetch a doctor!”

“—not breathing.”

Flossie’s mother was on her knees, keening out a shrill wail. Her father was shouting somewhere off in the distance. Flossie’s eyes broke away from the trickle of blood seeping slowly across the marble floor and latched onto Victoria.  

The girl was standing several feet away from the shattered chandelier, looking down at Teddy with an eerie, almost serene, expression on her ghastly face. Flossie’s rage turned into something sharp and fierce and utterly unbridled. Before she had time to think, she found herself marching over to the specter, raising her arm to deliver a resounding slap.

Her hand slipped like smoke through Victoria’s cheek, sending her stumbling. Flossie caught herself and let loose the scream that had been swelling inside her all evening.

 “Go away! Get out of here and leave us alone!”

Once she started yelling, Flossie found she couldn’t stop. The words kept erupting from her mouth like bitter bile. 

“I’m glad we broke your carriage that night. I’d do it again if I could, a thousand times over. You deserved exactly what you got, you devil.”

When Flossie finally emerged from her red haze of fury, the shocked silence around her seemed louder than the initial chaos of the chandelier hitting the floor. It struck her then, the word that was forming in people’s minds, as they turned their aghast faces toward her. A title worse than spinster, or witch, or specter. 

Murderer. 

The stares felt like a sea of judgement crashing down on her. Shame and terror fell like stones upon her chest, squeezing all the air from her lungs. Flossie swiveled back toward Victoria, just in time to catch the ghost of a smile flashing across her mouth.

Then Victoria vanished.